Satisfy your good-taste, with Mrs. Goodman's scrumptious flavor experiences! Scratch-made ButterCream-Iced & Standard or Specially Decorated Cakes, Cupcakes, or Cutout Cookies for any Occasion, including Weddings.

Enjoy a full line variety of our fresh & flavorful Cookies, ButterCream Iced & seasonal/holiday Decorated Cutout-Cookies, Thanksgiving-quality Fruit Pies and Cream Pies, Dessert Breads, Dessert Bars, and Scones.

Make sweet dreams come true with Mrs. Goodman's delicious time-tested recipes for your family, friends, or those in your business, schools, or social groups/meetings/gatherings.

Live a distance away? Our delicious scratch-made recipes are well worth the trip! Our customer base is comprised of those from near and far. 

Welcome!

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Company is a retail bakery located at 901 High Street, in beautiful Worthington, Ohio.

Call ahead, or stop in, to place your orders for Birthdays, Baby Showers, Holidays, Weddings, Anniversaries, Graduations,...etc, or simply dessert.  

Visit our warm & friendly retail showroom, and enjoy the readily available showcased array of our most delicious, made-from-scratch Baked Goods of all kinds! 

Store hours are from 9 am to 6 pm, Monday-Friday, and 9 am to 5 pm Saturdays (Closed Sundays).   

Our goal is to provide friendly service and indescribably delicious baked goods. 

 

About Us

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co. Gift Cards Now Available!

Inquire with Customer Service.

Store Hours:

Monday thru Friday-- 9 am to 6 pm
Saturday-- 9 am to 5 pm
Sunday-- Closed 

Click an Image below for Christmas Specials Page!

Valentine's Decorated Round Cakes, Heart-Shaped Cakes, Cutout Cookies, and our New Heart-Shaped Big Cookies and Fruit Pies!  You're Gonna Love them.

Valentine's Decorated Round Cakes, Cutout Cookies, Cupcakes, and our New Heart-Shaped Big Cookies and Fruit Pies.

You're Gonna Love Them!