Call us at: 614-888-7437

email at:

Store Hours: Monday thru Friday-- 9 am to 6 pm--Saturday-- 9 am to 5 pm Sunday-- Closed

Mrs. Goodman's Easter Offerings
Celebrate this very special time of year with some of Mrs. Goodman's most delicious decorated desserts.

In addition to the Easter Specials below, Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.'s normal line of Cakes, Cutout Cookies, Cookies, Pies, Dessert Bars, and Scones, are available to order ahead for pick-up, and may include any of your requested decorations. The main Easter pick-up day is the Saturday before Easter Sunday.

Easter Dessert Specials

# Renaissance Easter-Egg Cake $39.95
A two-layer, 3-dimensional (9"x6"x5") egg shaped cake, with your choice of Vanilla or Chocolate cake, with Raspberry, Vanilla ButterCream frosting, and snowy edible glitter. Choose from Sage Green, Wedgwood Blue, Lavender, or Peach shell-colors, with an ivory lace overlay. (Serves 8-10)


# Decorated Easter-Egg Single Layer Cake $19.95                          Single layer, 9"x 6" half egg shaped Vanilla or Chocolate cake, covered with Vanilla butter-cream icing, and decorated with Easter egg design with pastel colors. (Serves 4 to 5)


# Easter Lamb Cake $44.95

Your choice of Chocolate or Vanilla cake, decorated with ButterCream Icing!


# Daffodil Cake $29.95                                                                    An elegant 10" Angel food--Orange Meringue cake, with Orange ButterCream icing, and decorated with an edible Daffodil. (Serves 12 to 16).

# Easter Cross Cake $42.95--if vanilla or chocolate cake.

Comes on a1/2 Sheet cake board.  Serves 12 to 16.

3-D Easter Bunny Cake $32.95--if vanilla or chocolate

Serves 6 to 8.


# Pineapple-Mandarin-Orange Upside-down Cake 7"--$20.95// 10"--$28.95                                                                              Caramelized pineapple and mandarin oranges atop a moist, buttery sour-cream cake. This delight is delicious as is, but even better with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, or a dollop of whipped cream. (7" cake serves up to 6 // 10" serves up to 12).


# Regular Cutout Cookies $1.50 ea. or, $16.70/Doz.                   Delicious circle cutout cookies, topped with our famous ButterCream icing, sprinkled with seasonally colored sugars.

# Easter-Cross Iced Cutouts $1.40 ea. or, $16.80/Doz.

# Special Easter Decorated Cutouts $1.95 or, $23.40/Doz.                     Chick, Bunny, or Circle cutout cookies, decorated with Easter designs.

# Easter Egg Cutout Cookies $2.25 ea.                                            Xtra large & thick egg-shaped cutout cookies, with ButterCream Easter egg decoration.

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.
901 High Street
Worthington, OH 43085

Phone:  614-888-7437
E-mail at:

****Please call or email ahead to order, so we may better serve you****

Send SMS
Call from mobile
Add to Skype
You'll need Skype CreditFree via Skype